RETURN TO MAIN PAGE


Finnish Air Force Performance Trials on
Messerschmitt Bf 109 G-2, WNr. 14 783 'MT-215'.

English Transation by 'Hkuusela'.


The Messerschmitt Bf 109G-2 WNr. 14 783, MT-215 in operational service in Finland. (Via Keskinen/Stenman/Niska.)


Notes

TO THE RIGHT : The first 16 Me-109-G-2 fighters ready for the ferry flight to Finland at Wiener-Neustadt Flugzeugwerke on the 3rd of March 1943. The third from the right, GJ + QA is soon to become MT-215.
(Via Keskinen/Stenman/Niska.)


    The test subject of these Finnish trials was from the last batch of 350 Bf 109G-2s produced by W.N.F. as WNr. 14 783 somewhere between October - December 1942, in the 14 501 -14 850 production block. In FAF service it was designated as 'MT-215'.

    The Finnish pilots flew the first 16 of the Bf 109Gs, numbered from MT-201 to MT-216, to Finnland by themselves, taking off from Wiener-Neustadt on the 10th of March 1943 and arrived in Helsinki three days later. 13 more G-2s were received in May. In total Finland received 48 G-2s which were numbered from MT-201 to MT-248, and 109 examples of the G-6 model (numbered from MT-401 to MT-514).

    The Finnish Air Force achieved 663 victories with the Messerschmitt Bf 109Gs during 1943 and 1944, while losing 32 fighters in combat or to anti-aircraft fire.16 aircraft were lost in accidents and 8 were destroyed on ground. 23 pilots were lost - an impressive exchange ratio of 25 : 1.

    MT-215 was assigned to 1/LeLv 34, and was piloted by Sgt. E. Peltola. It was tested on 5 April 1943 at Malmi while being flown Kapt. Pekka Kokko, performance trials were done between 12:15 and 13:05 on that day. The results of these tests are seen below. On 29 July 1943, the aircraft crashed. Up until that time, it scored 2 aerial victories, and logged 52 hours 30 mins of flight time.

    BELOW : MT-215, piloted by Capt. Lahtela, during it`s ferry flight to Finnland.
    Note the non-retractable tailwheel of these late production aircraft.
    (Via Keskinen/Stenman/Niska)
  
    As a late production Bf 109G-2, WNr. 14 783 / MT-215 was fitted with an enlarged, non-retractable tailwheel as opposed to the previously retrractable one; this change caused -12km/h loss of speed at SL. This needs to be kept in mind when comparing the results with previous trials of the Bf 109G featuring retractable tailwheels.

    The then (March 1943) authorized maximum output of 1310 PS at 0km, ie. 100% throttle, Steig- und Kampfleistung, at a nominal 2600 R.P.M. and 1,3 ata MAP, were used through the tests.

The results are noted to be corrected to CINA and for compressibility effects, various intrument errors. Test flights were performed in order to eliminate windage errors (these are not reproduced here).


Maximum level Speed.


Maximum speed achieved at SL was 522 km/h, and 636 km/h at 6,3 km altitude, and 552 km/h at 10 km altitude.

     During the tests, 1.3-1.32 ata and 2540 RPM was realized, though such small variations were within tolerance, the lower RPM and/or other factors appear to have somewhat impaired the supercharger`s performance, and thus may have reduced altitude performance, as seen from the performance curves : the rammed rated altitude of 6,3 km was considerably below not only the nominal value (of 7 km) of the DB 605 A, but also the typically obtained, avarage 6,6-6,7 km rated altitude. For this reason is it interesting to extrapolate the level speed curves of MT-215 to 7 km rated altitudes, which shows an extrapolated speed of ca. 650 km/h. The extrapolated values show matching result with those obtained on Bf 109G-4 WNr. 19 968, that was tested by the NII VVS in a very similiar configuration (ie. tailwheel was non-retractable in that case as well) in October 1943. This points to that the poor high altitude performance shown by MT-215 was likely to have been caused by a defective supercharger and/or lower supercharger speeds due to lower engine RPM..


Climb rate and time.


Initial climb rates measured were 20.6 m/sec at SL, increasing to 24.7 m/sec at 1700m altitude. Climb to 5000m in ca. 4 min 6 secs.

        The climb results - 4 mins 6 seconds to 5km altitude - are in generally good agreement with the measurements of  Bf 109G-1 trials at E-Stelle Rechlin (time to 5km : 4 min 11 seconds), at ERLA Flugzeugwerke in Germany (4 min 30 secs); as well as with the results obtained with the captured  Bf 109G-2 WNr. 14 513, by the NII VVS in the USSR (4 min 24 secs).

        There`s, however a strong deviation, a 'spike' is displayed at ca. 1900m altitude compared to the aforementioned results, even though the shape of the climb curves follows closely the normal DB 605A-1 power curve characteristics. which develops it`s peak power output at around 2 km altitude in climbs, at the rated altitude of the supercharger`s 1. gear, or Bodenlader (M.S. gear FTH in RAF terms); all other Bf 109 test show the same phehomenon. The large scale deviation from other tests is observed from 0m up to ca. 2,5 km altitude, which prompted some, especially as it combined with a very impressive 24,7 m/sec (4860 fpm) peak climb rate for this particular Bf 109G, to dismiss the results as abberant. In contrast to the climb curve region of 0-2,5 m altitude, the curve follows closely the characteristic climb curve and values of  other Bf 109G climb tests.

        The test report gives the explanation to the presence of this 'spike' - the effect of the radiator flaps opening, and their varying drag, on climb rate.

German calculations typically assume a standard radiator flap position, referred to as Steigflugstellung (or climbing position), at which the radiator`s exit flaps (Kühlerklappen) are open 220 mm wide, or apprx. half-open, and 74mm at the variable the inlet (Einlaufflippen), in order to provide imcreased airflow during the slow-speed climbs. Such measures would keep the coolant temperature low at an optimum 85 C value, but the engine itself would tolerate temperatures as much as 115C safely up to 10 minutes duration, and the automatic thermostat not interfere up to 100C temperature, which could be sustained indefinietely, as noted on page 4 of the DB 605 A-B Motoren-Karte, Ausgabe Oktober 1942 .

        The Steigflugstellung is assumed in the calculations up to the VDH (rated alt, FTH), after which it is assumed to gradually close to the minimum-drag Schnellflugstellung position, depicted on the right. This latter assumption was more like for practical purposes, to simplify drag calculations from the variable flap movements by assuming a constant, predictably decreasing value above the VDH, as opposed to the real-life behaviour of the automatically controlled radiator flaps which shut 1000-2500m above or even before climbing to the VDH in reality.

        The actual flight trials performed by Messerschmitt A.G. only vaguely follow such theoretical considerations; the position of the radiator flaps - and thus the measured performance - greatly varies between as little as 130-150mm  and wide-open as 350mm.

       The Finnish trials of MT-215 are no exception. The report notes that climb speeds choosen for the trials were higher (300 km/h IAS) than prescribed in the manual for optimum climb speed (280 km/h). This resulted in higher speed airflow and more effective cooling for the radiators.
    As a result, it's noted that the radiator flaps would not open until the altitude of 2500 m was reached in climb, reducing drag considerably and resulting in increased rate of climb in the 0-2500 m altitude range - in short, a perfectly normal phenomenon, if we understand how airspeed, the cooling airflow, collant temperature, automatic thermostatically controlled, variable radiator exit flaps and their varying drag effects the flight performance of the Bf 109G.





- 4 -


MT-215 : Test Flight.



    3 April 1943

Weather observations at Tampere airfield
Velocity on the track
 Onboard Instruments

Notes

Time
b
mm Hg
t
C
y
kg/m3
v
km/h
v+
km/h
va
km/h
Δv
km/h

 9,15-10,25
10,55-11,55

745
745

-0,3
+0,7

1,266
1,260
{426
{360
 520
433
366
527
425
355
520
+ 8
+11
+ 7



weather observations at Tampere airfield :
                         8,00   b = 744,1 mm Hg   t = -2,0 C°
                        10,35   b = 745,2 mm Hg   t = +0,4 C° wind 34° 4 m/sek
                        13,35   b = 746,0 mm Hg   t = +1,6 C°

Values on the table are interpolated from the latter data.



- 14 -



    Malmi 5 April 1943 at 12.15-13.05                                Pilot : Kapt.P. Kokko

ha
m
b
mm Hg
ym
kg/m3
z
sec
w
m/sec
hCINA
m
Notes
  0

 1000

 2000

 3000

 4000

 5000

 6000

 7000

 8000

 9000

10000
746

665

587

517

456

398

348

302

262

227

196


1,174

1,075

.966

.862

.777

.702

.633

.566

.505

.446


44

40

52

56

9

64

74

70

105

160


21,3

24,7

18,9

17,2

17,2

15,1

13,4

13,7

9,0

5,9

640

1630

2620

3620

4620

5620

6620

7610

8610

9600


 na = 2580 1/min
 n  = 2540 1/min

 Load:
  Fuselage armament
  and full ammunition
  load. Fuel: 400 dm3




MT-215 : Time to Altitude.



hCINA
wm
m/sec
z
min
  0

 1000

 1900

 3000

 4000

 5000

 5600

 6000

 7000

 8000

 9000

10000

11000


21,6

23,5

21,2

19,0

18,1

16,6

16,2

14,5

11,9

9,3

6,7

2,1



0,8

1,4

2,3

3,2

4,1

4,7

5,1

6,2

7,6

9,4

10,9








MT-215: Climb speed and manifold pressure during climb.




    Malmi 5 April 1943 at 12.15-13.05                                Pilot : Kapt.P. Kokko

ha
m
hCINA
m
ym
kg/m3
va
km/t
v
km/t
aa
ata
a
ata
Notes
  0
 1000
 2000
 3000
 4000
 5000
 6000
 7000
 8000
 9000
10000
  +140
 1130
 2130
 3120
 4120
 5120
 6120
 7110
 8110
 9110
10100

1,221
1,126
1,024
 .907
 .817
 .737
 .666
 .600
 .536
 .473
 .419

300
300
300
290
285
285
280
270
250
230
210

313
325
341
351
364
383
396
403
397
391
383
1,30
1,31
1,31
1,30
1,31
1,31
1,21
1,10
 .94
 .80
 .68
1,30
1,31
1,31
1,30
1,31
1,31
1,21
1,10
 .94
 .80
 .68
 At airfield :
  Atmospheric pressure = 747,6 mm Hg
  Temperature  = +11,2° C
  Atmospheric pressure
  measured with onboard
  manifold pressure gauge =
   = 1,018 ata


Notes of pilot:

At 2500m coolant radiator flaps open fully for the first time.
After that varying between open and closed position.
Above 5500m manifold pressure dropping during climb.
Practical ceiling 10 500m.
Climbs were executed with greater than optimal climbing speed,
in order to improve cooling.
Opening of the radiator flaps noticably decreases the rate of climb.




MT-215: Level speed tests.


    Malmi 5 April 1943 at 12.15-13.05                                Pilot : Kapt.P. Kokko

ha
m
h
m
ym
kg/m3
va
km/h
v1
km/h
v
km/h
na
1/min
n
1/min
aa
ata
a
ata
   10
 1000
 2000
 3000
 4000
 5000
 6000
 6300
 7000
 8000
 9000
10000
  +140
 1130
 2130
 3120
 4120
 5120
 6120
 6420
 7110
 8110
 9110
10100

1,221
1,126
1,024
 .907
 .817
 .737
 .666
 .645
 .600
 .536
 .473
 .419

515
518
520
500
480
465
463
465
432
408
380
320
523
547
575
589
596
610
639
652
629
630
628
566

522
546
572
584
589
600
626
636
614
614
610
552
2580
2580
2580
2580
2580
2580
2580
2580
2580
2580
2580
2580
2540
2540
2540
2540
2540
2540
2540
2540
2540
2540
2540
2540
1,30
1,31
1,32
1,31
1,30
1,30
1,30
1,30
1,19
1,04
 .94
 .74

1,30
1,31
1,32
1,31
1,30
1,30
1,30
1,30
1,19
1,04
 .94
 .74


Notes.  Maximum velocity v is calculated from value v1 with compressibility
        correction added.


Notes of Pilot.  Radiators are closed at maximum velocity.
                 Above 6300 m manifold pressure dropping.

Load : Fuel 400 dm3, fuselage weapons and full ammunition load.








MT-215: Test flight.



      
       Test flights were performed at Malmi airfield. Therefore
exact data is lacking in the areas of boost pressure, weight
distribution, etc. Thus it is hard to compare this result with other
sources.
       Test were performed without special test flight instrumentation.
To compensate for this to an extent, an atmospheric probe measurement
was made during the test flight.
       Conditions were relatively close to CINA-values.
Thus the results are more accurate.



A. Instrumentation check.



1. Speedometer.

      
Maximum level speed test could not be performed perfectly, because the
test track was far off the starting site.Despite this, maximum level
speed runs were performed in four directions. Velocity and wind direction
data were derived from these results. Other diagrams suggest that wind
had slightly altered during the tests.
       Nothing special with the speedometer correction curve.


2. Air pressure gauge.

       Altitude meter was checked and corrections applied to calculations.
Otherwise there were no means to make sure the pitot-tube gave correct
static pressure.

3. Engine instrumentation.

       R.P.M. and manifold pressure gauges were checked. The charts show
both measured and absolute values.



B. Climb Tests.



       The results of climb test are naturally somewhat inaccurate,
as no special test flight instrumentation were available. The spread
in the measurements on climb rate curve is partially due to opening
of the radiator flaps. Velocity was higher than optimal to improve
cooling.

       The first F.T.H. can only be estimated. Based on on the rate
of climb it is 2200m as a function of pressure. The second F.T.H. is
5800m.

RoC curve recommends for the practical ceiling value 11 700m and a
theoretical ceiling of 12 100m. It is important to note that no data
measurements exist at very high altitudes.


C. Level Speed Tests.


                The results of top speed test can be regarded as accurate.
        Full Throttle Heights are 2600m and 6700m as function of pressure.
                Compressibility is taken into account. The compressibility
        correction is applied to velocity v1. The correct and final speed
        are presented in charts as v.





Sources :




Last updated 23 May 2007.
Work in progress.

All rights reserved.
email at : kurfurst@atw.hu
Total Site Page loads :